Assuming you would wish to achieve this objective constitutionally how is the electorate going to get Parliament, comprised overwhelmingly by members of the Tory and Labour parties to pass a law making their party membership illegal?
If you were to make only the Tory and Labour Party illegal what would stop the reforming under another name?
Perhaps you would want to make all parties illegal but is hard to see how a parliamentary democracy could work without parties. Nothing would ever get done although you might see that as desirable. It would in any case difficult to define what a political party is. Is an informal group with shared interests in achieving their objectives in Parliament a political party? That after all is how political parties came about.
Last edited by: CGNorwich on Wed 28 Aug 19 at 17:52
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
VxFan |
|
24 Aug 19 21:14 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
Haywain |
|
21 Aug 19 14:29 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
21 Aug 19 14:33 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
21 Aug 19 15:26 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
sherlock47 |
|
21 Aug 19 15:38 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
Duncan |
|
21 Aug 19 17:50 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
21 Aug 19 18:23 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
sooty123 |
|
21 Aug 19 19:08 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
21 Aug 19 19:19 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
Zero |
|
21 Aug 19 19:29 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
sooty123 |
|
21 Aug 19 19:30 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
21 Aug 19 19:40 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
sooty123 |
|
21 Aug 19 19:55 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82.. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
21 Aug 19 20:10 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 8.. new |
|
Lygonos |
|
21 Aug 19 20:36 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume .. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
21 Aug 19 20:37 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 8.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
21 Aug 19 21:26 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume .. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
21 Aug 19 21:36 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
21 Aug 19 21:43 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
sooty123 |
|
21 Aug 19 21:47 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
Fullchat |
|
21 Aug 19 21:12 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
Lygonos |
|
21 Aug 19 14:48 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
21 Aug 19 15:16 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
21 Aug 19 15:27 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
21 Aug 19 15:38 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
21 Aug 19 18:02 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
Ambo |
|
21 Aug 19 16:14 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
sooty123 |
|
21 Aug 19 16:20 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
21 Aug 19 16:24 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
Robin O'Reliant |
|
21 Aug 19 17:48 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
Haywain |
|
21 Aug 19 18:16 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
21 Aug 19 19:49 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
Rudedog |
|
21 Aug 19 21:46 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
Ambo |
|
23 Aug 19 10:43 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
Ambo |
|
24 Aug 19 10:09 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
23 Aug 19 21:24 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
Kevin |
|
23 Aug 19 21:43 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 82 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
23 Aug 19 21:53 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky pies new |
|
smokie |
|
26 Aug 19 10:56 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky pies new |
|
VxFan |
|
26 Aug 19 19:51 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky pies new |
|
smokie |
|
26 Aug 19 20:35 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky pies new |
|
VxFan |
|
27 Aug 19 01:58 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky pies new |
|
sooty123 |
|
27 Aug 19 07:24 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky pies new |
|
Lygonos |
|
27 Aug 19 09:48 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky pie.. new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
27 Aug 19 10:09 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky pi.. new |
|
Zero |
|
27 Aug 19 10:45 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky p.. new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
27 Aug 19 10:57 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky p.. new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
27 Aug 19 10:59 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky .. new |
|
DP |
|
27 Aug 19 11:13 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
zippy |
|
27 Aug 19 23:53 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
28 Aug 19 00:06 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 8.. new |
|
smokie |
|
28 Aug 19 09:23 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky pi.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
27 Aug 19 12:29 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky pie.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
27 Aug 19 12:31 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky pi.. new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
27 Aug 19 12:35 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky p.. new |
|
Manatee |
|
27 Aug 19 13:24 |
|
True to form, Boris tells porky p.. new |
|
sooty123 |
|
27 Aug 19 14:10 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Runfer D'Hills |
|
27 Aug 19 16:23 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
27 Aug 19 16:29 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Runfer D'Hills |
|
27 Aug 19 16:43 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
27 Aug 19 16:54 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Runfer D'Hills |
|
27 Aug 19 16:56 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
27 Aug 19 17:02 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Runfer D'Hills |
|
27 Aug 19 17:05 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
legacylad |
|
27 Aug 19 17:11 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
tyrednemotional |
|
27 Aug 19 17:25 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Runfer D'Hills |
|
27 Aug 19 18:25 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
28 Aug 19 09:28 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
smokie |
|
28 Aug 19 09:46 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
commerdriver |
|
28 Aug 19 10:24 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
28 Aug 19 17:26 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
sooty123 |
|
28 Aug 19 10:28 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
sooty123 |
|
28 Aug 19 10:37 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Robin O'Reliant |
|
28 Aug 19 12:13 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Zero |
|
28 Aug 19 13:23 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
28 Aug 19 14:07 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Robin O'Reliant |
|
28 Aug 19 14:32 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
28 Aug 19 15:08 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
28 Aug 19 16:26 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
28 Aug 19 17:51 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Duncan |
|
28 Aug 19 18:12 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
28 Aug 19 18:26 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 8.. new |
|
Zero |
|
28 Aug 19 22:12 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume .. new |
|
No FM2R |
|
28 Aug 19 23:10 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
29 Aug 19 06:00 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Bobby |
|
29 Aug 19 10:35 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
28 Aug 19 16:45 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
commerdriver |
|
28 Aug 19 17:10 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
smokie |
|
29 Aug 19 00:02 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
29 Aug 19 09:27 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
29 Aug 19 11:35 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
30 Aug 19 00:07 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
No FM2R |
|
29 Aug 19 12:00 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Robin O'Reliant |
|
29 Aug 19 12:20 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
CGNorwich |
|
29 Aug 19 12:29 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Robin O'Reliant |
|
29 Aug 19 13:08 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
commerdriver |
|
29 Aug 19 13:14 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Robin O'Reliant |
|
29 Aug 19 14:03 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Manatee |
|
29 Aug 19 14:05 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Falkirk Bairn |
|
29 Aug 19 18:09 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
29 Aug 19 20:19 |
|
Brexit Discussion - Volume 83 new |
|
Bromptonaut |
|
29 Aug 19 23:53 |
|