Children looked after by their grandparents often develop better than those put in nurseries
- Youngsters cared for by relatives are more 'emotionally secure' and have wider vocabularies
Young children looked after by middle-class grandparents develop better vocabulary than those in nurseries, a study has revealed.
They are ‘significantly ahead’ by the age of three due to the amount of one-on-one time they spend with a loving adult.
The head start relates more to children who live in better-off households, where grandparents tend to have higher levels of education and ‘are likely to be better carers than formal carers’ in relation to the early learning of new words.
'Granny nannies': Around 5.8 million grandparents look after young ones which saves parents almost £2,000 a year on average (file picture)
For less well-off homes, the researchers believe that while children are not put at a ‘significant’ disadvantage in terms of vocabulary, their grandparents ‘may not confer the advantages’ formal care provides.
A similar distinction was suggested in social development.
The researchers found a ‘positive association between socio-emotional development and being looked after by grandparents among more educated families’, which was still apparent by the age of five.
By contrast, children from disadvantaged backgrounds were thought to receive a slight benefit from formal childcare.
The findings were published in a review of childcare studies by researchers from the Institute for Fiscal Studies, Bryson Purdon Social Research, Essex University’s Institute for Social and Economic Research and the National Centre for Social Research.
Funded by charity the Nuffield Foundation, the conclusions highlight the important role grandparents can play through ‘informal’ childcare.
Half of pre-school children whose parents work are looked after part of the time by relations, usually grandparents.
At primary school age, the proportion increases to 60 per cent and then 82 per cent by the time children start secondary school.
The report says that most parents choose to leave their children with grandparents for ‘positive’ reasons such as the ‘caring environment’ rather than simply because they can’t afford formal childcare.
The researchers, led by social scientist Caroline Bryson, examined the Millennium Cohort Study, which follows almost 19,000 children.
‘By the age of three, they [those looked after by grandparents] were significantly further ahead than children in centre-based care,’ they said.
‘Evidence suggests in terms of vocabulary development, if you are from an advantaged background, grandparents are likely to be better carers than formal carers, maybe because of differences in their education levels or potentially through differences in type of engagement that both groups have with the children in their care.’
Most watched News videos
- Moment police officer is dragged down by car driver in tactical stop
- Met Police release video of an arrest during a protest on York Road
- Thousands join Tommy Robinson for far-right demo in central London
- Moment woman kills pensioner with Alzheimer's in 'red mist' shove
- 16-year-old student asks Rishi Sunak why he 'hates' young people
- Moment police arrest Tommy Robinson protester at London demonstration
- Nigel Farage says he backs Trump 'more than ever' after conviction
- Police clash with far-left activists at far-right protest in Germany
- Friends filmed in final embrace before being swept away in floods
- Hillary Clinton reacts to Donald Trump verdict with a wry smile
- Heroes who told Putin warship to 'Go f*** yourself' finally go home
- Heartbreaking moment two men threaten to jump from asylum seeker site