Motoring Discussion > Fifth Gear - Volume 3 Miscellaneous
Thread Author: VxFan Replies: 94

 Fifth Gear Crash Test - TeeCee
>> In other words, the speed of the oncoming solid car/object is immaterial.

Er, that's not actually true.
Assuming that both vehicles are of approximately the same mass, if both are going at the same speed, then both will experience the same deceleration as if they had run into a concrete wall. This is what the Mythbusters did.

If, on the other hand, one is going significantly faster than the other, then the slower one will be propelled backwards and will experience rather more deceleration than if it had hit a wall at its orginal speed, while the faster one will experience less than if it had a wall at it's original speed.

I suspect that the actual deceleration experienced by both would be that as if both were travelling at the average of the two speeds.

Secondly: "oncoming solid car/object". If the oncoming object were indeed solid, then again it gets nasty for the car. Its crumple zone is forced to accomodate both its momentum and that of the solid object, causing greater damage to the car.

This only works if both objects are of around the same mass, both are travelling at around the same speed and both are of similar construction.
 Messages Author Date
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  VxFan 6 Nov 12 01:08
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  mikeyb 5 Nov 12 20:24
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  rtj70 5 Nov 12 20:27
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  Zero 5 Nov 12 20:35
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  Dave_ 5 Nov 12 20:36
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  Zero 5 Nov 12 20:49
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  rtj70 5 Nov 12 20:49
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  Lygonos 5 Nov 12 21:12
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  Manatee 5 Nov 12 20:50
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  MD 5 Nov 12 21:22
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  Lygonos 5 Nov 12 21:30
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  zippy 6 Nov 12 01:05
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  zippy 6 Nov 12 01:08
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  Lygonos 6 Nov 12 07:07
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  L'escargot 6 Nov 12 08:28
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  John H 6 Nov 12 08:50
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  TeeCee 1 Mar 13 08:54
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  John H 6 Nov 12 08:12
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  Lygonos 6 Nov 12 08:29
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  John H 6 Nov 12 08:43
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  Dutchie 6 Nov 12 08:57
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  Zero 6 Nov 12 08:53
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  Dog 6 Nov 12 09:27
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  Zero 6 Nov 12 09:30
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  bathtub tom 6 Nov 12 09:51
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  Dog 6 Nov 12 10:05
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  WillDeBeest 6 Nov 12 10:38
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  No FM2R 6 Nov 12 11:33
  
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  Lygonos 6 Nov 12 13:13
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  madf 6 Nov 12 13:20
  
 Fifth Gear Crash Test  Dutchie 14 Mar 15 17:43
 Fifth Gear - 11th Feb  VxFan 13 Feb 13 01:56
 Fifth Gear - 11th Feb  lancara 13 Feb 13 08:06
 Fifth Gear - 11th Feb  VxFan 13 Feb 13 09:27
 Fifth Gear - 11th Feb  VxFan 16 Feb 13 17:37
 Fifth Gear - 11th Feb  Manatee 16 Feb 13 18:22
 Fifth Gear - 11th Feb  VxFan 16 Feb 13 21:36
 Fifth Gear 18th Feb  VxFan 19 Feb 13 00:21
 Fifth Gear 18th Feb  VxFan 1 Mar 13 01:11
 Fifth Gear - 16th Sep  VxFan 16 Sep 13 00:51
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  L'escargot 16 Sep 13 09:44
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Boxsterboy 17 Sep 13 12:42
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  VxFan 14 Mar 15 16:58
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  swiss tony 15 Mar 15 21:36
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  VxFan 16 Mar 15 10:21
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Roger. 16 Mar 15 12:01
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Slidingpillar 16 Mar 15 13:48
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Zero 15 Mar 15 22:12
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  madf 16 Mar 15 06:52
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Crankcase 16 Mar 15 08:12
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Zero 16 Mar 15 08:18
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Crankcase 16 Mar 15 10:28
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  WillDeBeest 16 Mar 15 10:29
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Crankcase 16 Mar 15 10:44
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  WillDeBeest 16 Mar 15 10:59
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Zero 16 Mar 15 11:16
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Crankcase 16 Mar 15 11:46
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Roger. 16 Mar 15 12:04
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  swiss tony 16 Mar 15 22:01
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  VxFan 1 Oct 18 14:13
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  R.P. 1 Oct 18 14:48
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  No FM2R 2 Oct 18 15:08
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Dog 1 Oct 18 19:43
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  R.P. 7 Oct 18 21:41
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  VxFan 8 Oct 18 02:11
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  rtj70 8 Oct 18 08:51
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  VxFan 8 Oct 18 10:31
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Zero 8 Oct 18 10:41
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Boxsterboy 8 Oct 18 16:36
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  No FM2R 8 Oct 18 10:45
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Fullchat 8 Oct 18 11:12
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Duncan 8 Oct 18 14:45
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  No FM2R 8 Oct 18 15:04
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Fullchat 8 Oct 18 15:50
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  martin aston 8 Oct 18 16:34
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Duncan 8 Oct 18 19:19
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Zero 8 Oct 18 16:54
 Fifth Gear  Bobby 30 Dec 18 23:32
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  VxFan 7 Oct 19 02:20
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  R.P. 7 Oct 19 07:55
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  VxFan 7 Oct 19 10:30
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  R.P. 7 Oct 19 14:24
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  VxFan 7 Oct 19 19:35
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  R.P. 7 Oct 19 20:02
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  R.P. 13 Oct 19 14:03
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  VxFan 13 Oct 19 20:16
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  R.P. 13 Oct 19 22:22
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  R.P. 13 Oct 19 22:25
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  VxFan 22 Oct 19 10:39
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  VxFan 28 Oct 19 10:27
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  R.P. 28 Oct 19 12:04
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  Bobby 28 Oct 19 19:14
  
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  VxFan 28 Oct 19 20:13
 Fifth Gear - Volume 3  bathtub tom 28 Oct 19 20:39
  
 Fifth Gear - Recharged  VxFan 13 Dec 21 13:27
Latest Forum Posts