Non-motoring > Necessary or disgrace?
Thread Author: sooty123 Replies: 95

 Necessary or disgrace? - sooty123

>> Its this thinking that had it 10 years late and billions of pounds over cost.
>> A gas turbine is not a gas turbine. The location of the engine requires exclusive
>> use of the Rolls-Royce BR710, an expensive power plant built in small numbers

the engines weren't delayed they were built on time. The maker or design of the engines wasn't a problem nor was the location. The 700 series has been built in pretty large numbers.





>> If you were to design long range maritime patrol or ASUW you would design based
>> round a turbo prop. The design of the Nimrod is the way it is because
>> the use of the comet was forced upon the builders. It was a bad choice.
>> It was a bad choice 60 years ago and it still is.
>>

Why would you built it around a turbo prop, they can do the job and are good at it. But don't pretend that there is some inheirted fault with using nimrod, it is an excellent, and would have been, multi role a/c. What marks turboprop a/c out as a better design than the nimrod?
 Messages Author Date
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 19:36
 Necessary or disgrace? new Perky Penguin 28 Jan 11 19:46
 Necessary or disgrace? new Zero 28 Jan 11 19:47
 Necessary or disgrace? new Iffy 28 Jan 11 19:51
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 19:52
 Necessary or disgrace? new Mark 28 Jan 11 19:53
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 20:02
 Necessary or disgrace? new Mark 28 Jan 11 20:13
 Necessary or disgrace? new Ian (Cape Town) 28 Jan 11 20:17
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 20:19
 Necessary or disgrace? new Mark 28 Jan 11 20:52
 Necessary or disgrace? new MD 28 Jan 11 19:53
 Necessary or disgrace? new MD 28 Jan 11 19:55
 Necessary or disgrace? new Fenlander 28 Jan 11 19:56
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 20:00
 Necessary or disgrace? new Zero 28 Jan 11 20:05
 Necessary or disgrace? new MD 28 Jan 11 20:06
 Necessary or disgrace? new Iffy 28 Jan 11 20:07
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 20:12
 Necessary or disgrace? new Zero 28 Jan 11 20:16
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 20:22
 Necessary or disgrace? new Zero 28 Jan 11 20:25
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 20:29
 Necessary or disgrace? new Zero 28 Jan 11 20:40
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 20:54
 Necessary or disgrace? new Zero 28 Jan 11 20:59
 Necessary or disgrace? new Bromptonaut 28 Jan 11 21:05
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 21:11
 Necessary or disgrace? new CGNorwich 28 Jan 11 20:12
 Necessary or disgrace? new Kevin 28 Jan 11 20:14
 Necessary or disgrace? new R.P. 28 Jan 11 20:18
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 20:25
 Necessary or disgrace? new RattleandSmoke 28 Jan 11 20:19
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 20:22
 Necessary or disgrace? new RattleandSmoke 28 Jan 11 20:23
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 20:27
 Necessary or disgrace? new RattleandSmoke 28 Jan 11 20:28
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 20:31
 Necessary or disgrace? new R.P. 28 Jan 11 20:32
 Necessary or disgrace? new Zero 28 Jan 11 20:41
 Necessary or disgrace? new Fenlander 28 Jan 11 21:04
 Necessary or disgrace? new R.P. 28 Jan 11 21:13
 Necessary or disgrace? new Fenlander 28 Jan 11 21:20
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 21:29
 Necessary or disgrace? new Zero 28 Jan 11 21:23
 Necessary or disgrace? new madf 28 Jan 11 21:18
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 21:24
 Necessary or disgrace? new Zero 28 Jan 11 21:27
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 21:30
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 21:34
 Necessary or disgrace? new Zero 28 Jan 11 21:43
  
 Necessary or disgrace? new Mark 28 Jan 11 21:54
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 21:55
  
 Necessary or disgrace? new midlifecrisis 28 Jan 11 21:48
 Necessary or disgrace? new Zero 28 Jan 11 21:54
  
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 21:58
  
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 22:20
 Necessary or disgrace? new John H 28 Jan 11 22:51
  
 Necessary or disgrace? new rtj70 28 Jan 11 23:12
 Necessary or disgrace? new rtj70 28 Jan 11 23:14
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 23:23
 Necessary or disgrace? new rtj70 28 Jan 11 23:30
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 23:31
 Necessary or disgrace? new rtj70 28 Jan 11 23:36
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 28 Jan 11 23:50
 Necessary or disgrace? new rtj70 28 Jan 11 23:55
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 29 Jan 11 00:10
 Necessary or disgrace? new hobby 29 Jan 11 08:53
 Necessary or disgrace? new midlifecrisis 29 Jan 11 09:33
 Necessary or disgrace? new madf 29 Jan 11 09:37
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 29 Jan 11 10:28
 Necessary or disgrace? new Perky Penguin 30 Jan 11 07:30
 Necessary or disgrace? new R.P. 30 Jan 11 09:06
 Necessary or disgrace? new Perky Penguin 30 Jan 11 09:16
 Necessary or disgrace? new R.P. 30 Jan 11 09:21
 Necessary or disgrace? new hobby 30 Jan 11 09:45
  
 Necessary or disgrace? new R.P. 30 Jan 11 09:46
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 30 Jan 11 11:46
 Necessary or disgrace? new hobby 30 Jan 11 12:40
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 30 Jan 11 13:03
 Necessary or disgrace? new Zero 30 Jan 11 13:24
 Necessary or disgrace? new hobby 30 Jan 11 16:28
 Necessary or disgrace? new Tooslow 30 Jan 11 17:01
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 30 Jan 11 11:18
 Necessary or disgrace? new Perky Penguin 30 Jan 11 16:33
 Necessary or disgrace? new R.P. 30 Jan 11 16:35
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 30 Jan 11 22:41
 Necessary or disgrace? new swiss tony 30 Jan 11 22:44
 Necessary or disgrace? new Bromptonaut 30 Jan 11 22:44
  
 Necessary or disgrace? new swiss tony 30 Jan 11 22:45
 Necessary or disgrace? new Perky Penguin 31 Jan 11 08:15
  
 Necessary or disgrace? new sooty123 31 Jan 11 17:40
  
 Necessary or disgrace? new Perky Penguin 29 Jan 11 07:46
 Necessary or disgrace? new Perky Penguin 31 Jan 11 10:26
 Necessary or disgrace? new smokie 11 Mar 11 00:19
 Necessary or disgrace? new Ian (Cape Town) 29 Jan 11 13:46
Latest Forum Posts